Dear Prof B,
Thank you for your submission to the Journal of Universal Rejection.
I don't know who this William Caxton fellow is. But more importantly, I read the first paragraph of your paper and I still don't know when or where he lived. May I suggest that, like every good biography ever written, you start your paper with the sentence "William Caxton was born in (YEAR) in (LOCATION)." I understand that your paper may not be a biography of William Caxton. Nonetheless, we are going to have to agree with the other journals and reject your submission.
Caleb Emmons, PhD
Journal of Universal Rejection